I decided to review the holiday edition, and you might think I’m about to be a total Grinch, but honestly? The editing this time around really surprised me. It feels tighter, cleaner, and way more intentional than previous seasons, which already put me in a better mood than I expected.
I actually loved the format of bringing back contestants who’d already proven themselves in earlier seasons. There’s something fun about seeing familiar faces mixed in with three new professional bakers. Altogether, the six contestants tackle hyper-realistic gingerbread men, Christmas trees, and even giraffes yes, giraffes while competing for their share of a very festive £75,000. The challenges are whimsical without feeling too chaotic, and the holiday theme gives everything a warmer, more playful vibe.
The judging panel is also a major upgrade. Kristen Bell, Pierson Fodé, Lamorne Morris, and Michael Urie seem to have a sharper eye than some judges we’ve seen before. They bicker, they second-guess themselves, and they sometimes get hilariously dramatic honestly, it adds to the charm. Their reactions feel a bit more genuine this season, which makes the judging segments more enjoyable instead of something you just sit through.
And yes, Miley Day returns as the host. It’s still as over-the-top as ever, but I have to give credit where it’s due: the set design this season is gorgeous. Festive without being tacky, bright without being blinding. Also, the fact that the whole thing is only three episodes really works in its favor. It’s short, sweet, and doesn’t drag out the joke or the format.
There’s a nice touch of competitiveness just enough to keep things interesting but overall the vibe is much more cheerful and lighthearted. I finished the season with a small smile, which is more than I expected going in.
If you’re looking for something fun to have on in the background while baking, wrapping presents, or even working, this little holiday edition is exactly the kind of cozy, low-stakes series you might enjoy.